Shopper marketing blog

Category management in Fast-Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG) is a delicate balance of art and science. While data-driven insights have always played a key role, product reviews have become a powerful tool for sharpening strategies and boosting category performance. These reviews offer a goldmine of consumer feedback and can guide decisions from product reformulation to marketing focus.

This post will explore how incorporating product reviews into your category management strategy can unlock new opportunities for brands and retailers. The five areas of opportunity are:

1. Understanding consumer preferences
2. Optimising product performance
3. Driving category growth
4. Supporting retailer listing decisions
5. Enhancing the impact of shopper marketing

Introducing new products at the start of the year can be quite a journey. The path to success for any new product development is fraught with challenges and often leads to a dead end. According to Harvard Business Review, 90% of new products fail within their first year despite significant investments by FMCG companies.

To give your new products the best possible start in the New Year, we will highlight the crucial importance of consumer reviews. Here are four strong reasons why obtaining a substantial number of consumer reviews as early as possible is crucial for the success of your new offerings.

1. TO BUILD CONSUMER CONFIDENCE
2. TO DRIVE CONSIDERATION
3. TO CREATE AN AURA OF POPULARITY
4. TO KEEP UP WITH THE COMPETITION

* Coke Image from Coca-Cola, final image copyright CheckoutSmart

PS For even more on why reviews are critical for NPD, see our post 10 Reasons why Shopper Reviews are Vital for Successful New Products.

Introduction

In the fiercely competitive beverage industry, standing out on the shelf involves more than just striking designs and impactful displays. Today's consumers seek authenticity and trustworthiness in the brands they select. This is where genuine customer reviews become crucial, significantly swaying purchasing decisions.

Recognising this trend, Heineken launched an innovative campaign for Inch’s Cider, utilising CheckoutSmart’s SmartReputation program to tap into the power of genuine customer feedback. This case study delves into how CheckoutSmart assisted Heineken in transforming ordinary customer reviews into a compelling shopper marketing program, enhancing the brand's reputation and influencing buyer behaviour across Tesco and Sainsbury's.

Images from Heineken materials

When a product’s rating falls below the critical 4.0 mark, it is easy to panic or bury your head in the sand. After all, consumers rely heavily on reviews to guide their choices, and a poor score can signal trouble ahead for your products. Yet, rather than viewing these ratings as a dead-end, they can represent a valuable opportunity for growth and improvement.

At CheckoutSmart, we see these poor reviews not as a problem but as a unique opportunity to transform your product with SmartReformulation.

The Hidden Opportunity in Poor Reviews

Our analysis reveals that the bottom 20% of products with at least 30 reviews in UK supermarkets since 2023 have an average rating of less than 4.0. This figure underscores a vital truth: these products don’t need more reviews—they need reformulating to succeed.

Instead of trying to drown out the negativity with more reviews (which is rightly banned under recent legislation), it’s time to listen to your customers. Using the right tools, these less-than-ideal reviews can become a goldmine of insights that guide product improvement, revitalise your brand, and boost your sales.

The 3Ps of Supermarket Shopper Marketing

When launching your long-planned and lovingly-developed grocery NPD into supermarkets, it’s critical that it appeals to and is tried by the target consumers. Getting it into the hands, baskets and homes of the right grocery shoppers can be a daunting task, but here’s what you need to remember and how to go about it.

Supermarket shoppers are the key to NPD success as they are the ones who actually pick the product off the shelves and take it home, regardless of whether they, or someone else in their household is the end consumer. This is the crux of  Shopper Marketing and understanding the art  of getting shoppers to Pause, Pick up & Pay for your product is known as the 3 Ps of shopper marketing.

Are you preparing to launch new products? Harvard Business Review reports that 90% of new products fail within the first year, despite significant investments in research, development, marketing, and advertising.

To improve your chances of success, it's important to obtain consumer reviews as soon as possible. Here are ten reasons why consumer reviews are crucial for all new grocery products:

 Reasons why shopper reviews are critical to new products are:

1. Answering for shoppers: "Will I like it?"
2. For instant shopper credibility
3. You look like a bestseller
4. Shopper read reviews for products they don't know
5. The in-store opportunity
6. Reap long term benefits
7. Increasing popularity of reviews with shoppers
8. Your competitors are growing reviews
9. Actionable insights
10. Avoid early delists

We surveyed members of CheckoutSmart to understand their experiences of shopping during Covid-19 and their views on how their behaviour will change when things "more or less return to normal". In total 4,324 members responded, over 3,100 of whom are also online grocery shoppers. 

The survey focused on how their grocery shopping experience had changed pre and during Covid-19 restrictions and their personal expectations on how their behaviour will change going forward. This blog article contains a summary of the most relevant results. More detail on specific topics may be available, please contact us to hear more.

The most significant finding is that online shopping could still grow even faster post Covid if retailers can address the two major concerns shoppers have of slot availability (which is surely just a matter of time) and the cost of delivery which must surely come down with scale and the the recent move by Amazon. 

With all the pressure from retailers and the fact that many brands have postponed their FMCG NPD launches until the second half of the year, we thought it would be helpful to review the shopper marketing options available to support NPD in supermarkets.

For those new to working with the major supermarket retailers in the UK, navigating your way through the variety of shopper marketing options can seem like the proverbial minefield. We've spent the best many years working for FMCG suppliers and supporting them as an agency. With our collective experience, we have broken down the pros and cons of each option in the hopes it will help you identify the best course for your product's unique marketing challenge.

We've grouped our thoughts under the kinds of questions you should be asking yourself when you are planning a shopper marketing campaign: